[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[council] August 2, 17:00 CET -- 12 votes received (from 18 max)
Council,
Amadeu already explained why the NC is rushing -- the calendar
for the WG-A was set from the ICANN Board calendar:
step N August 26 -- ICANN BoD meeting
step N-1 August 5 (August 26 - 21 days for public comments sent
to the www.icann.org website) -- deadline for
the NC to ICANN forwarding
step N-2 August 4 (few hours -- few days would be better)
for the NC to summarize votes and comments added to votes
step N-3 should be July 31, was postponed to August 2
-- deadline for the NC vote
step N-4 week between July 26 and July 30 to summarize
public comments sent to the www.dnso.org
and produce the document for vote by WG-A co-chairs
step N-5 2 weeks for public comments sent to the www.dnso.org website
(it was between July 11 and July 25)
The CALENDAR for June-November 1999 was posted on the website
in the mid of June and certainly before the meetings in San Jose
http://www.dnso.org/dnso/calendardnso.html
I quote the initial dead lines (for WG-A only):
|| June 11th, 1999
|| Creation of Working Group A (done).
|| July 7th, 1999
|| Working Group A presents its report and it is published in the
|| DNSO website for public comment.
|| July 24th, 1999
|| Closing of comment period on Working Group A report.
|| July 26th or 27th, 1999 (circa)
|| Meeting(s) of the Names Council to decide on the final report
|| that will be sent to the ICANN Board on Conflict Resolution
|| Policy. Details for these meeting(s) will be decided on June
|| 25th.
|| July 31st, 1999
|| Report on Dispute Resolution Policy sent to the ICANN
|| Board.
Probably the secretariat should have summarize it and send a reminder
every week since mid July -- I take it for WG-D plan for every
next text to vote.
>From this first vote experience I also take the following:
- state clearly that the voting ballot will come From: voteNN@dnso.org
(even if this was very well understood by some
from ga@dnso.org or announce@dnso.org who tried to vote
-- it get bounced, of course)
- remind the NC that the email address from the electorale list
is indeed very important
- avoid to vote during the weekend
The main document for ICANN and its Supporting Organizations
(http://www.icann.org/bylaws-09apr99.html,
ICANN Bylaws as Revised May 27, 1999),
ARTICLE VI-B, Section 2, i, states:
(d) If two-thirds (2/3) of the members of the NC determine
that the DNSO process has produced a community consensus,
that consensus position shall be forwarded to the
Board as a consensus recommendation, along with all
materials or other information that could reasonably
be relevant to the Board's review of that determination,
including (but not limited to) the dissenting statement(s) of
any member(s) of the NC. If more than one-half (1/2)
but less than two-thirds (2/3) of the members of the NC
determine that the DNSO process has produced a
community consensus, that position may be forwarded to
the Board as a NC recommendation, along with statements
of majority and minority views, and any separate or
dissenting statement(s) of any member(s) of the NC.
Any proposed recommendation that is not supported by
an affirmative vote of one-half (1/2) of the members
of the NC may be returned to the body from which
it originated, or may be assigned to a new body,
for further work. In such a case, the NC may report
to the board the lack of a consensus and the steps,
if any, it plans to take from this point forward with
respect to this particular recommendation. The NC is
responsible for ensuring that the Board is informed
of any significant implementation or operational
concerns expressed by any responsible party.
As of August 2, 17:00 we received 12 votes (from 18 max).
I hope that the ICANN will accept we extend by 24 hours.
| Electorate list -- 18 persons
| -----------------------------
| [ ] Europe () - Fay Howard fay@ripe.net (ccTLDC)
| [ ] Africa (.gh) - Nii Quaynor quaynor@ghana.com (ccTLDC)
| [voted] AsiaPac (.nu) - Bill Semich bill@mail.nic.nu (ccTLDC)
| [ ] NorthA (.us) - Jon Englund jenglund@itaa.org (Business)
| [ ] Europe (.es) - Javier Sola javier@aui.es (Business)
| [voted] NorthA (.us) - Theresa Swinehart Theresa.Swinehart@wcom.com (Business)
| [voted] NorthA (.us) - Don Telage dont@netsol.com (gTLDC)
| [voted] NorthA (.us) - David R. Johnson djohnson@wilmer.com (gTLDC)
| [voted] NorthA (.us) - Phil Sbarbaro psbar@hanson-molloy.com (gTLDC)
| [ ] LatinAC (.ar) - Tony Harris harris@cabase.org.ar (ISPCPC)
| [voted] AsiaPac (.jp) - Hirofumi Hotta h.hotta@hco.ntt.co.jp (ISPCPC)
| [ ] Europe (.de) - Michael Schneider sastre@anwalt.de (ISPCPC)
| [voted] Europe (.es) - Amadeu Abril i Abril amadeu@nominalia.com (Registrars)
| [voted] AsiaPac (.jp) - Richard Lindsay richard@interq.ad.jp (Registrars)
| [voted] NorthA (.us) - Ken Stubbs kstubbs@corenic.org (Registrars)
| [voted] NorthA (.ca) - Jonathan Cohen drvcarrington@echelon.ca (IPC)
| [voted] NorthA (.us) - Caroline Chicoine chicoinc@PeperMartin.com (IPC)
| [voted] Europe (.be) - Ted Shapiro Ted_Shapiro@mpaa.org (IPC)
DNSO Secretariat