Re: [tor-udrp] Re: [council] UDRP Review Task Force Selected

[Nilda Vany Martinez Grajales <vany@sdnp.org.pa>]

Elisabeth, Caroline, Milton and all:

I share Elisabeth concerns...please, answer the questions she made in order to have a
better idea if this commitee is properly balanced between different sectors, points of
view, law codes, members by constituencies, regions, etc.

Best Regards
Vany

Elisabeth Porteneuve wrote:

> > From: "Milton Mueller" <Mueller@syr.edu>
> >
> > The Chairs are non-voting.
>
> So what ?
> You do not answer my question, neither address the problem I raise.
>
> Elisabeth Porteneuve
> ccTLD NC rep
> --
> >
> > >>> Elisabeth Porteneuve <Elisabeth.Porteneuve@cetp.ipsl.fr> 08/29/01 04:15PM >>>
> >
> > > From: "Chicoine, Caroline G." <CCHICOINE@thompsoncoburn.com>
> > > To: "'council@dnso.org'" <council@dnso.org>,
> > >         "'tor-udrp@dnso.org'"
> > >      <tor-udrp@dnso.org>
> > > Subject: [council] UDRP Review Task Force Selected
> > > Date: Mon, 27 Aug 2001 10:21:15 -0500
> > >
> > > The Task Force was selected by Milton and I yesterday.
> > >
> > > There were only three areas where we had more than one nominee -
> > > Complainant, ADR expert, and academic expert.  Given that the majority of
> > > the nominees in other categories were from North America, and given that we
> > > had excellent nominees in these categories from outside North America, we
> > > eliminated any North American nominees in these categories and selected from
> > > there.  Fortunately, the ccTLDs provided three geographical diverse nominees
> > > so we chose the one form Africa since we did not otherwise have such a
> > > nominee.
> > >
> > > Once I accumulate their emails, I will forward them to the Secretariat and
> > > ask that she create an email group for us so that I can notify the selected
> > > individuals and we can begin discussions.
> > >
> > >
> > >  <<UDRP Nominees.DOC>>
> > >
> >
> > Caroline,
> > Milton,
> >
> > I had some personal difficulties to be on line, it is a little
> > in late, I am sorry.
> >
> > Once I decoded the format I do not read, and completed with e-mails,
> > I get 20 persons plus
> > Chairs: cchicoine@thompsoncoburn.com
> >         mueller@syr.edu
> >
> > I have two observations:
> > 1. shall I add you as Chair and Milton as well ? Why then 2 candidates
> >    from 2 constituencies when ccTLD were refused more than one seat
> >    (bringing people from 3 continents)?
> > 2. the simple arithmetics is:
> >    16 - NA, 14 NA plus two Chairs
> >     3 - EU
> >     1 - LAC
> >     1 - AF
> >     1 - AP
> > 3. how many representatives are from countries with Roman law
> >    (as opposed to case law ?), or from countries not using case law ?
> >
> > I am not a lawyer, but as mathematician I wish express here my
> > strongest objections as to representation of this TF.
> > The terms of reference appears without problem, but the outcome does.
> >
> > Elisabeth Porteneuve
> > ccTLD NC rep
> > --
> >
> >
> > Business Constituency, Sarah Deutsch (NA) <sarah.b.deutsch@verizon.com>
> > ccTLD Constituency, Neil Duncan Dundas (AF) <ndundas@africaip.com>
> > gTLD Constituency, Jeff Neuman (NA) <Jeff.Neuman@NeuLevel.com>
> > IP Constituency, J. Scott Evans (NA) <jse@adamspat.com>
> > ISP Constituency, Antonio Harris (LAC) <harris@cabase.org.ar>
> > NCDNH Constituency, Michael Froomkin (NA) <froomkin@law.miami.edu>
> > Registrar Constituency  Michael Palage (NA) <michael@palage.com>
> > Complainant (or representative), Katrina Burchell (EU) <Katrina.Burchell@unilever.com>
> > CPR Panelist, M. Scott Donahey (NA) <msd@tzmm.com>
> > CPR Provider, F. Peter Phillips (NA) <pphillips@cpradr.org>
> > eResolution Panelist, Ethan Katsh (NA) <katsh@legal.umass.edu>
> > eResolution Provider, Dr. Joelle Thibault (NA) <jthibault@eresolution.com>
> > NAF Panelist, James A. Carmody (NA) <carmody@lawyer.com>
> > NAF Provider, Tim Cole (NA) <tcole@arb-forum.com>
> > Respondent (or representative), John Berryhill (NA) <jberryhill@ddhs.com>
> > WIPO Panelist, Maxim Waldbaum (NA) <mwaldbaum@salans.com>
> > WIPO Provider, Erik Wilbers (EU) <erik.wilbers@wipo.int>
> > GA Member, Dan Steinberg (NA) <synthesis@videotron.ca>
> > Independent ADR expert, Joon Hyung Hong (AP) <joonh@chollian.net>
> > Independent academic expert, Graeme Dinwoodie (EU) <gdinwood@kentlaw.edu>
> >
> > --
> >
> >

--
Nilda Vany Martinez Grajales
Information Technology Specialist
Sustainable Development Networking Programme/Panama
e-mail: vany@sdnp.org.pa
http://www.sdnp.org.pa