Re: [ga] Transfers TF Final Report

[Alexander Svensson <alexander@svensson.de>]

At 12.12.2002 12:10, DannyYounger@cs.com wrote:
>With regard to (3), the average reader could well conclude that the TF 
>recommendations are more than somewhat lopsided in favor of the gaining 
>registrar... perhaps this is the major stumbling block that is preventing the 
>emergence of consensus on the recommendations.  It could well be the case 
>that those registrars that have the most to lose simply don't trust the 
>"presumption" that in all cases the Gaining Registrar will apply due 
>diligence to the authentication process, and that they consequently don't 
>wish to find themselves facing the financial and human resource burden 
>associated with determining whether the registrant "intent" to transfer was 
>legitimate.  

Danny,

The informed reader could also well conclude that some
of the more critical comments regarding the Task Force 
recommendations come from registrars which don't have
the most to lose, but which in fact lose the most --
because their customers are transferring their domains
to different registrars. [*] The TF recommendations, in 
my view as a registrant, make the transfer process a 
bit more predictable and easier for registrants. 

You are arguing that the Gaining Registrar may not want
to carry the "financial and human resource burden associated 
with determining whether the registrant "intent" to transfer 
was legitimate." In fact, it's the Gaining Registrar who
has a reason and an incentive to do the homework necessary 
for the transfer (the Losing Registrar can optionally check 
a second time with the registrant, but cannot block the 
transfer without good reason). 

As someone who has been through a transfer which failed 
and a transfer which succeeded, I think that reducing the
costs of switching (including the fear of losing the domain)
is an important step towards levelling the playing field
and more competition. As always, not everyone wants a 
level field in the first place.

Best regards,
/// Alexander

[*] Statistics on who loses and who gains are available
e.g. to registered users of http://www.sotd.info  

--
This message was passed to you via the ga-full@dnso.org list.
Send mail to majordomo@dnso.org to unsubscribe
("unsubscribe ga-full" in the body of the message).
Archives at http://www.dnso.org/archives.html