[ga] [fwd] Substance over rhetoric - a constructive challenge (from: edyson@edventure.com)

[Thomas Roessler <roessler@does-not-exist.org>]

For your information. Also, my congratulations to Alexander.

-- 
Thomas Roessler                          http://log.does-not-exist.org/




----- Forwarded message from Esther Dyson <edyson@edventure.com> -----

From: Esther Dyson <edyson@edventure.com>
To: <pindar@hk.super.net>, <carl@bildt.net>,
	<denisemichel@sbcglobal.net>, <tgcn143@attglobal.net>,
	<cecostello@hotmail.com>, <cecoste@emory.edu>, <oiteanu@iteanu.com>,
	<orobles@nic.mx>, <sdnpaf@intnet.bj>, <sdnpaf@hotmail.com>,
	<pindar@pacific.net.hk>, <tniles@uscib.org>, stellin@earthlink.com,
	Kevin.Murphy@computerwire.com, Mikael Pawlo <mikael@pawlo.com>,
	icann-alsg@lists.fitug.de, "Moore, James" <jmoore@geopartners.com>,
	Dave Farber <dave@farber.net>,
	"Juliana Gruenwald" <JGruenwald@bna.com>,
	Andy Mueller-Maguhn <andy@ccc.de>, Andy.Sullivan@reuters.com,
	"Keith Teare" <keith@realnames.com>,
	"Elliot Noss" <enoss@tucows.com>, <forum@atlargestudy.org>,
	"Johnson, David" <DJohnson@Wilmer.COM>
Date: Fri, 15 Mar 2002 05:30:04 -0500
Subject: [icann-alsg] Substance over rhetoric - a constructive challenge

[sorry for any double-postings]



Substance over Rhetoric:

A constructive challenge to the ICANN board, staff and other involved 
parties.


Yesterday the board of ICANN approved continued work on an At-Large 
membership “mechanism” and stated that it “wishes to move forward with 
energy and enthusiasm to build a meaningful structure for informed 
participation by the full range of Internet users, and seeks avenues to 
achieve these objectives that are bottom-up, self-organized, and 
self-sustaining.”

I would like to take these words at their face value and, before leaving 
Accra, make some concrete suggestions for moving forward. It’s obvious that 
ICANN itself has few resources (whatever its intentions) to move the ALM 
forward, and indeed the major activity needs to come bottom-up, from the 
community itself.  There is no staff person with spare time to dedicate to 
this effort, and from the community side, there are feelings ranging from 
betrayal and hostility to indifference.  How can we mend this situation?

For starters, this message is an attempt at transparency and 
concreteness.  Other than noncommittal discussions with Alexander Svensson 
(more below) and a couple of the ALSC members, I have not lined up support 
for these proposals. So these ideas are fresh and unvetted: I hope that 
those of you I am addressing directly will respond in kind, with ccs to all…

The basic idea is to move forward in tangible ways with the formation of a 
coherent, tangible At-Large membership, supported by a fulltime, committed, 
paid individual staffer as well as volunteer efforts.

It will require funding from a variety of parties (we cannot depend on 
ICANN alone) and some concrete actions.  This does not require broad 
consensus, but rather the actions of a few parties who I hope can 
ultimately gather broad support for their efforts. The Board on its 
side  is lukewarm/negative on elections, but willing for the most part to 
respond to evidence of a committed, transparent, issue-focused At-Large 
that could provide constructive input representing the public interest in 
ICANN policies (aside from its own role).

I’d like to suggest the following:

ICANN hires Alexander Svensson to manage At-Large outreach for the next 
year.  This position will be funded (here’s the challenge!) by my $10,000 
pledge, matched by institutions such as Harvard’s Berkman Center (which 
spent at least that much to send its own team to Ghana to observe the 
recent meeting), Markle, Bertelsmann, and the like, and a variety of 
interested companies who at least in principle have supported the notion of 
an At-large membership.  And perhaps even ICANN can allocate a small sum 
with “energy and enthusiasm.”

I have talked with Alexander. He is a PhD student from Hamburg, Germany, 
who is studying ICANN and is currently chairman of the DNSO  General 
Assembly. With some encouragement from a few more people, I think he would 
be willing to serve.  So far, he has demonstrated himself to be impartial 
and sensible and  has the calm, unassuming personality that should enable 
him to do this job effectively.  His first task would be to take over from 
Denise Michel (the executive director of the ALSC) all the communications, 
databases, lists of interested parties and other connections that will 
enable the transformation of the ALSC  At-Large Study Committee  into an 
At-Large Organizing effort.  Denise has agreed to help with the transition.

Once settled in, he should get in touch with all the individuals and 
organizations interested in furthering the At-Large and help them to 
self-organize. In addition, he will manage the online discussion (my 
suggestion is for one reference list, completely uncensored except for 
spam) and one or two moderated lists that ideally will focus on ICANN 
substance  things such as name-registration policies and international 
domain names  as well as on the role of the At-Large.

Ideally, the At-Large discussion should be focused on ICANN policies rather 
than just winning a seat at the table. Alexander may choose to present a 
variety of topics, offering substance and questions for discussion (for 
example, how should new TLDs be chosen, if at all?), making the At-Large a 
forum for learning as well as expression of opinions.

Alexander should also act as a liaison/staff to those ICANN Board members 
who wish to work with him, so that the At-Large can have an additional, 
active channel/advocate with the Board.

What happens after that?  A lot is still up in the air, with the board 
meeting in a private retreat in the next month or two, followed by the 
Bucharest board meeting at the end of June.  At the same time, there will 
be actions and statements by a variety of other parties, including various 
governments, and responses to the Lynn “reform” proposal.

An incipient At-Large membership should be part of that mix.  The 
discussions moderated by Alexander should help determine where it all goes.

So, I challenge all of you to support such an effort…or to come up with 
better or additional activities.  Thank you for your attention.

Please reply with any questions or constructive comments.

Esther Dyson


BACK TO THE FRONTIER - this year's PC FORUM with
Craig Barrett, Rick Belluzzo, Eric Schmidt... and you!
www.pcforum2002.com/pcforum/speakers.cfm
March 24 to 26


Esther Dyson			Always make new mistakes!
chairman, EDventure Holdings
writer, Release 3.0 (on Website below)
edyson@edventure.com
1 (212) 924-8800    --   fax  1 (212) 924-0240
104 Fifth Avenue (between 15th and 16th Streets; 20th floor)
New York, NY 10011 USA
http://www.edventure.com



---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: icann-alsg-unsubscribe@lists.fitug.de
For additional commands, e-mail: icann-alsg-help@lists.fitug.de


----- End forwarded message -----
--
This message was passed to you via the ga@dnso.org list.
Send mail to majordomo@dnso.org to unsubscribe
("unsubscribe ga" in the body of the message).
Archives at http://www.dnso.org/archives.html