Re: [nc-udrp] Work Assignments

[Ethan Katsh <katsh@legal.umass.edu>]

J. Scott -

        

I am ok
with this and I'll get in touch with Dan about dividing up the work.
Given that all the papers are connected to each other, however, figuring
out how to divide up the work may be a bit of a challenge.

Ethan

At 09:45 AM 12/13/2002 -0500, J. Scott Evans wrote:

UDRP WORK ASSIGNMENTS:

---

PAPERS

 1: Dinwoodie, Graeme
 
 the Max Planck study
Max Plank Institute Study -
http://www.intellecprop.mpg.de/Online-Publikationen/2002/UDRP-study-final-02.pdf

2: M. Scott Donahey
 
Designing Non-National Systems: The Case of the Uniform Domain
Name Dispute Resolution Policy, L. Helfer and G. Dinwoodie -
http://www.kentlaw.edu/depts/ipp/intl-courts/docs/dh.pdf

3 : Michael Froomkin
An executive summary of Professor Froomkin's paper.
 
4 :  Ethan Katsh* and Dan Steinberg
 
Fair.com, Prof. Michael Geist -
http://aix1.uottawa.ca/~geist/geistudrp.pdf

Fundamentally Fair.com? An Update on Bias Allegations and the
ICANN UDRP, Prof. Michael Geist -
http://aix1.uottawa.ca/~geist/fairupdate.pdf

The UDRP by All Accounts Works Effectively - Rebuttal to Analysis and Conclusions of Professor Michael Geist in "Fair.com?" and
"Fundamentally Fair.com?", INTA Internet Committee -
http://www.inta.org/downloads/tap_udrp_2paper2002.pdf

A Response to INTA's Rebuttal of Fair.com (Prof. Michael Geist)
- http://aix1.uottawa.ca/~geist/geistintaresp.pdf
 
5 : Tim Cole
 
Patrick L. Jones article at
http://www.udrplaw.net/UDRPReview1.htm
 
6 : Philip Sheppard
 
Rough Justice, Prof. Milton Mueller -
http://www.acm.org/usacm/IG/roughjustice.pdf

UDRP-A Success Story? A Rebuttal to the Analysis and Conclusions
of Professor Milton Mueller in Rough Justice, N. Branthover (INTA) -http://www.inta.org/downloads/tap_udrp_1paper2002.pdf

I think Ethan's memo speaks for itself and requires no further summarization.
*Ethan did not volunteer for this assignment.  I have volunteered him to assist Dan given the number of papers there are to review.  Ethan if my assumption that you would be willing to help out here was incorrect, I apologize in advance and I will try and get another volunteer to assist in this area.

---

SURVEYS
 
The following people have agreed to assist with the survey results:
 
Caroline Chicoine
Sarah Deutsch
Tony Harris
James Carmody
J. Scott Evans

---

I note that there are numerous Task Force members that did not respond to my request.  While I find this very disappointing, I believe that we have the field covered and can now move forward.  That being said, anyone that would like to assist with the survey response please contact me immediately so that we can parcel out some work to you in the next few days.
 
In this regard, we need to set benchmarks for when this work will be completed and distributed to the entire group.  Given that the holidays are upon us, I would suggest that we make every effort to have our tasks completed no later than January 10, 2003.  Please let me know if this timeframe is acceptable.
 
Caroline, I would ask that you spearhead coordinating the survey response team.  I'd like to hear back from everyone designated an assignment in this message no later than Monday, December 23, 2002.
 
Thanks again for you help!
 
J. Scott Evans
ADAMS, SCHWARTZ & EVANS, P.A.
jse@adamspat.com
PH:  (704) 375-9249
FX:  (704) 375-0729
 
I look forward to hearing back from each of you.