RE: [registrars] UNDER $6 PRICING BY NETSOL??

["Michael D. Palage" <michael@palage.com>]

Title: Your Domain Name and Full Feature Email Account

Bhavin:

 

This was a topic of discussion in Montevideo. The minutes from this meeting were initially lost but have now been located. David Washer will be providing these minutes to me shortly. However, to address your concerns I will summarize the discussions that took place in Montevideo. A number of registrars in attendance (four or five) raised concerns about allegations of registrants being offered domain name registration services for below $6. Based upon the informal numbers that were discussed, there appeared to be several hundreds of thousand of registrations that fell within this alleged marketing practice. Complicating matters was the fact that these alleged reseller contracts have confidentiality provisions preventing the parties from disclosing the price. Bruce Beckwith acknowledged that their reseller agreements had confidentiality provisions, and that they would not be disclosed.

 

Because all registrar contracts with ICANN contain no pricing restriction, it is legal within the parameters of the current contract for VeriSign-Registrar to provide domain name registration services at any price, even at zero dollars for the first year on transfers as some registrars have alleged reported.  On its face it makes sense that a registrar should be able to provide a service below cost if their are other value added services that they wish to provide. The question that most registrars ask, how do you compete when the largest registrars offering these services just happens to own the registry. A question was posed to Dan Halloran of whether the independent evaluation committee that is supposed to analyze the separation between VeriSign registry/registrar would be able to look into this matter. No answer has yet been provided, but I hope Dan will be able to give us an answer by next month's meeting. My personal interpretation of the contracts based upon Joe Simm's discussion in Melbourne is that this issue falls outside the scope of that review panel.

 

I would like to offer the following clarification to prevent your valid concerns from being undermined. I do not believe that NameZero is "owned" by Network Solutions. I believe that VeriSign is an investor in NameZero, which I also believe NameZero owns NamesDirect. VeriSign in fact has its fingers in a number of registrar operations. It acquired NameSecure and Registrars.com, I also believe it has an interest in dotTV which now has a registrar operation as well. I would encourage you to dig through VeriSign's SEC filings to find out the exact nature of their relationship/investment in these various companies.

 

Based upon ICANN's rather technical mandate, I do not believe that it has the power to address your concern. I believe that only an appropriate governmental agency tasked with ensuring competition in the marketplace would have standing to address this issue. If you would like I could place this item on the agenda for Marina del Rey and have it brought to the attention of the greater Internet community.

 

Best regards,

 

Michael D. Palage

 

 

 

-----Original Message-----
From: owner-registrars@dnso.org [mailto:owner-registrars@dnso.org]On Behalf Of Bhavin Turakhia
Sent: Wednesday, October 10, 2001 5:49 AM
To: Registrars@Dnso. Org
Cc: Directi; Divyank Turakhia
Subject: [registrars] UNDER $6 PRICING BY NETSOL??

I just got this mailer (REFER below this MAIL) and couldnt first believe that someone was allowing me to renew my domain for $4.95. I then realised that NameZero is owned by network solutions and since they have to effectively pay $6 to themselves they have actually a zero cost and can sell domains for lower than $6. I had mentioned these activities to Michael in my last meeting at Stockholm, of how I had heard general rumours of netsol selling domains for under $6 discreetly. But this notice now makes it public.

 

Isnt this similar to the entire DOJ crusade against Microsoft where microsoft was taking undue advantage of its monopoly in Operating Systems to sell its application software. I see Verisign using its effective monopoly in the Registry area to cannibalise sales in the Registrar area.

 

I can see standard arguments coming from them to the effect that they have this huge inventory that they gave out free and now they want to make some money of it etc etc. The bottomline point here however remains that ONLY VERISIGN can sell domains below $6 and still make a profit. No other registrar has this privilege. By nature of this arrangement therefore if Verisign utilises this benefit it amounts to unfair competition.

 

I am looking at various possibilities that I have heard about from the market. I am not claiming or guranteeing their truth. However I know of companies who claim that they get NSI domains for less than $6 by purchasing the domain for a price higher than $6 and then getting a marketing rebate which covers this cost. As to how much truth exists in these claims I do not know, however the point still remains that only Verisign can do this and no other registrar can, and there is no provision that requires inspection or audit of their practices to ensure that this is not done.

 

-----Original Message-----
From: ReclaimYourDomain [mailto:Reclaim@Namezero.com]
Sent: Wednesday, October 10, 2001 3:06 PM
To: divyank@directi.com
Subject: Just $4.95 to reclaim divyank.com

Your Domain Name and Full Feature Email Account - Just $4.95! Yes, Really
	Don't let go of  divyank.com when you can renew it for just $4.95! Dear Divyank, Renew divyank.com with Plus service and a full feature email account now for the low price of just $4.95 and avoid losing it forever.	Act Now to Avoid Losing divyank.com Forever! Renew Now For Only $9.95
$4.95 is an unheard-of price for a domain name alone, and this deal includes a full feature email account. -(yourname@divyank.com) A real email account based on your domain is the key to your online identity. Don't throw away this chance to take advantage of a full feature Web and POP mail account based on your domain name. Stop telling your friends and family your email account that's based on a work, ISP, or free mail address. That isn't your true online identity. Use email based on an address that they can remember - divyank.com, and that you can keep as long as you want to, not as long as someone else lets you. When you renew, divyank.com will be transferred into your name and you will be upgraded to our Plus service automatically.  The domain will be yours through the end of its current registration period (our records show 08-MAY-02). Renew your domain now. This is the easy way to ensure that you won't have to worry about someone else taking your domain name from you, and you can even extend your registration for 2 or 5 years for a special price. Click here to confirm your current registration before you renew to note the expiration date and determine which is the best term for you. Please note that divyank.com still points to a Namezero parking page and that we are currently accepting offers for the domain from current members or third parties.  Once such an offer is accepted, you will no longer be able to reclaim your domain. Don't risk the loss of divyank.com when just $4.95 buys your online idenitity right now! Best regards, The Namezero Team		Renew Now and Receive our Plus Service at a special price: LIVE Plus Member phone support line A Web-mail account with 10MB of e-mail space A NavBar you can hide (no advertising) Domain ownership transferred to your name (allow up to 2 weeks for updated Who-Is listing)
You are receiving this message as part of your Namezero Free service membership. To avoid receiving offers regarding the Namezero Free service, you must upgrade to our Plus service, transfer out of our service, or cancel the use of your Namezero domain.   If you have already upgraded your domain, please disregard this email.   Prices subject to change without notice.   This offer is non-transferable and available to Namezero registered members only and is subject to the terms of the Namezero service agreement located at:  http://www.namezero.com/support/policies/sup-pol_tosplus.shtml   To learn more about Namezero privacy agreement, please visit:  http://www.namezero.com/support/policies/sup-pol_privacy.shtml   Forgot your password?  http://controlpanel.namezero.com/forgot_password.jsp   If you would like to opt out of future emails about this domain, click here.   For additional questions, please do not reply to this email, instead contact our customer service group at: http://namezero.com/support/helpcenter/email_support.jsp   ã2001 Namezero.com Inc.  All Rights Reserved 011008