b03results.html

ICANN/DNSO

DNSO General Assembly
RESULTS of the Vote for Election Rules for the DNSO GA

23 March 2001

RESULTS of the Vote for Election Rules for the DNSO GA

Election Rules proposed by Harald Alvestrand: http://www.dnso.org/dnso/notes/2001.GA-chair-election-rules-v0.2.html

Electorate: 295 persons in a http://www.dnso.org/secretariat/b03rosterindex.html, Vote Roster, when the ballot was sent out

Voted: 67

Participation: 22.7%

Vote results:

57 votes [X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
3 votes [X] No, the Election Rules should not be adopted.
7 votes [X] I abstein.

According to the voting rules in use http://www.dnso.org/dnso/notes/2000.GA-voting-rules.html:

5. In the case where the question is a new rule or rule change for the GA, the number of votes in favour of the winning alternative must be at least 2/3 of cast votes, with a minimum number of cast votes being the lower of 20% of the registered voters or 100 votes.

The number of cast votes is 67.

To be adopted, an alternative shall be supported by "2/3 of cast votes", i.e. 45, with a minimum number of cast votes being the "lower of 20% of the registered voters or 100 votes", i.e. 59.

Therefore the proposed rules are adopted (57 of "Yes" is greater than 45, the number of cast votes, 67, is greater than 59).

Vote records.

Each voter got an aknowledge quoting his ballot as received.
Each voter may recognize its ballot in the attached public record by his personnal code.
We had several special cases, fixed as follows:
1. all votes with "yes" or "y" instead of "x" (upper and lower case alike) counted as "x"
2. one voter put "No, the Election Rules should not be adopted.", outside of ballot, counted as "No" -- b03:K886fZ
3. one voter put "Yes", outside of ballot, counted as "Yes" -- b03:Kf1d1Z
4. one voter put "Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted", outside of ballot, counted as "Yes" -- b03:Kf092Z
5. one voter put only one line "I abstein" without reminding part of ballot, counted as abstention -- b03:Ka95bZ
6. two voters edited ballot, suppressing lines with unwanted alternatives, fixed -- b03:K1a2aZ, b03:Kd469Z
7. one voter changed secretariat's typo "abstein" to the correct English "abstain", counted as abstention -- b03:Kcc7aZ
We received eleven (11) delivery-reports related to the GA Voting Registry emails. Published in http://www.dnso.org/secretariat/rosterproblems.html. One problem fixed since then.
Besides 67 casted votes, five additional voters replied to the Secretariat Reminder message with "Basic outline exemple template", instead of reply to gavote@dnso.org message with their personalized code -- four (4) yes, one (1) abstain, all discarded.

Public record

 
Ballot sent with       3 choices
           b03:[ ] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
           b03:[ ] No, the Election Rules should not be adopted.
           b03:[ ] I abstein.
 
Electorate of     295 persons, casting one vote each
Ballots received from      67 persons (sorted by arrival time)
           Elisabeth Porteneuve
           Kendall Dawson
           Paul Stahura
           David Farrar
           Richard W. Kroon
           Danny Younger
           Kevin M. Kelly
           Chris Jara
           Kevin Cronin
           Alec Barea
           ken stubbs
           Camron Johnson
           Micha Reisel
           Alejandro Pisanty
           Darrell Greenwood
           Clara Collado
           Kristal Preschern
           Scott Hollenbeck
           Bruce James
           Marc Schneiders
           Michael Castello
           Joanna Lane
           Harald Tveit Alvestrand
           Markus Ulysses Hafner
           Peter de Blanc
           Jan Gora
           David Ervin
           Mohammed Mohsin Ali
           Michael Miller
           Mohammed Zeeshan Ahmed
           Alberto Pellizzari
           Kilian Wahl
           Alexander Svensson
           Steffen Goewe
           Nikhil Narayanan
           Lee Lowery
           Jean-François C. (Jefsey) Morfin
           Erick Iriarte
           Chris Anderson
           Henning Grote
           Dany Vandromme
           Jonathan Weinberg
           Stephen Boyle
           Dave Geurs
           Chuck Gomes
           Michaela Gerberich
           Joop Teernstra
           Roger Klaus
           Rod Dixon
           Jeffrey Williams
           Roberto Gaetano
           Darryl G Lynch
           Michael Haffely
           Jack F Freund III
           Tobias Kleck
           Michael F. McNulty
           Anna Pinkes
           Frederic Wilf
           Curt Stafford
           Giacomo Catenazzi
           Dirk Lorenz
           Charles Shaban
           Jean Pierre Galeazzi
           David Keegel
           Mark Poole
           Annie Renard
           Sotiris Sotiropoulos
 
Casted votes (sorted by personal code)
           b03:K1945Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K1a28Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K1a2aZ casted  1 votes
           b03:K1b03Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K2406Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K2698Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K2a0dZ casted  1 votes
           b03:K2a3eZ casted  1 votes
           b03:K31a3Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K3538Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K3558Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K3589Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K37b2Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K3976Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K3e11Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K409eZ casted  1 votes
           b03:K452eZ casted  1 votes
           b03:K4c3bZ casted  1 votes
           b03:K4d0dZ casted  1 votes
           b03:K4d20Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K572cZ casted  1 votes
           b03:K5768Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K5b1dZ casted  1 votes
           b03:K5f59Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K603cZ casted  1 votes
           b03:K6807Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K6d90Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K703bZ casted  1 votes
           b03:K7413Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K7f31Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K8069Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K8675Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K886fZ casted  1 votes
           b03:K8b23Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K8b78Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K8c59Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K8cc0Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K8cefZ casted  1 votes
           b03:K9816Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K9d68Z casted  1 votes
           b03:K9eb9Z casted  1 votes
           b03:Ka245Z casted  1 votes
           b03:Ka95bZ casted  1 votes
           b03:Kaae3Z casted  1 votes
           b03:Kaf4cZ casted  1 votes
           b03:KafafZ casted  1 votes
           b03:Kb7e7Z casted  1 votes
           b03:Kb8fdZ casted  1 votes
           b03:Kb937Z casted  1 votes
           b03:Kb9b3Z casted  1 votes
           b03:Kbc9dZ casted  1 votes
           b03:Kc36bZ casted  1 votes
           b03:Kc376Z casted  1 votes
           b03:Kcc7aZ casted  1 votes
           b03:Kd1cdZ casted  1 votes
           b03:Kd28eZ casted  1 votes
           b03:Kd469Z casted  1 votes
           b03:Kd520Z casted  1 votes
           b03:Kd5f0Z casted  1 votes
           b03:Ke05dZ casted  1 votes
           b03:Ke2dcZ casted  1 votes
           b03:Kf092Z casted  1 votes
           b03:Kf186Z casted  1 votes
           b03:Kf1d1Z casted  1 votes
           b03:Kf326Z casted  1 votes
           b03:Kfc5eZ casted  1 votes
           b03:Kffb0Z casted  1 votes
 
Nb of casted votes      67
Nb of choices who received more than zero votes       3
           57 Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
            3 No, the Election Rules should not be adopted.
            7 I abstein.
 
Public results (sorted by personal code)
 b03:K1945Z:[Yes] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K1a28Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K1a2aZ:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K1b03Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K2406Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K2698Z:[x ] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K2a0dZ:[yes] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K2a3eZ:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K31a3Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K3538Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K3558Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K3589Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K37b2Z:[ X] I abstein.
 b03:K3976Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K3e11Z:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K409eZ:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K452eZ:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K4c3bZ:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K4d0dZ:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K4d20Z:[ X ] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K572cZ:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K5768Z:[X] I abstein.
 b03:K5b1dZ:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K5f59Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K603cZ:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K6807Z:[x ] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K6d90Z:[ x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K703bZ:[x ] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K7413Z:[ X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K7f31Z:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K8069Z:[ X ] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K8675Z:[Y] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K886fZ:[x] No, the Election Rules should not be adopted.
 b03:K8b23Z:[ X ] I abstein.
 b03:K8b78Z:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K8c59Z:[Y] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K8cc0Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K8cefZ:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K9816Z:[X] I abstein.
 b03:K9d68Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:K9eb9Z:[X] I abstein.
 b03:Ka245Z:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Ka95bZ:[x] I abstein.
 b03:Kaae3Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kaf4cZ:[x] No, the Election Rules should not be adopted.
 b03:KafafZ:[X] No, the Election Rules should not be adopted.
 b03:Kb7e7Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kb8fdZ:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kb937Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kb9b3Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kbc9dZ:[x ] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kc36bZ:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kc376Z:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kcc7aZ:[X ] I abstein.
 b03:Kd1cdZ:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kd28eZ:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kd469Z:[Yes] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kd520Z:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kd5f0Z:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Ke05dZ:[X ] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Ke2dcZ:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kf092Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kf186Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kf1d1Z:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kf326Z:[x] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kfc5eZ:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 b03:Kffb0Z:[X] Yes, the Election Rules should be adopted.
 
--End

Information from:

DNSO General Assembly RESULTS of the Vote for Election Rules for the DNSO GA

DNSO General Assembly
RESULTS of the Vote for Election Rules for the DNSO GA