ICANN/DNSO
Full record of vote by the GA to designate its representative to the Names Council Review Task Force, June-July 2001 |
Wednesday 11 July 2001, 21:00 Paris time.
Re: b06
Vote by the GA to designate its representative to the Names Council Review Task Force
cf. http://www.dnso.org/dnso/notes/2001.DNSO-GA-ReviewTF.html
The vote was conducted by the DNSO Secretariat using Instant Runoff Vote according to the Election Rules adopted by the GA and published in: http://www.dnso.org/dnso/notes/2001.GA-chair-election-rules-v0.2.html.
The members to the Watchdog Committee in 2001 election are:
The time for the vote was:
Begins: Tuesday 3 July 2001, 16:00 UTC, 18:00 CET (Paris),
Ends: Tuesday 10 July 2001, 16:00 UTC, 18:00 CET (Paris)
A. The final result:
Roberto Gaetano is elected.
B. Information about ballots received:
Number of ballots received: 81
One (1) ballot empty:
1. b06:K37e4Z
which adds to number of valid ballots, and increases majority requirement in the first step.
Besides ballots we received eighteen (18) Delivery-Reports:
1 b06:K3c9cZ 2 b06:K1c9aZ 3 b06:Kf927Z 4 b06:Kd627Z 5 b06:K38ebZ 6 b06:K6f87Z 7 b06:Ke29eZ 8 b06:K4240Z 9 b06:K4171Z 10 b06:K6db2Z 11 b06:K289fZ 12 b06:K7f7aZ 13 b06:Kfdd0Z 14 b06:Kc770Z 15 b06:Kdf8bZ 16 b06:K3cf8Z 17 b06:Kc770Z 18 b06:K6218Z
One (1) ballot was discarded:
1. b06:KabcdZ
sent by user who was not on electorate list at the time the vote started.
C. Adjustements:
Besides trashing HTML format, the following adjustements were made:
1. b06:K247eZ, line END__: completed 2. b06:Kaa39Z, line END__: completed 3. b06:Kc6c0Z, line END__: completed 4. b06:K9359Z, missing square bracket added received: > b06:K9359Z:[ 3 David Farrar replaced by: > b06:K9359Z:[ 3] David Farrar 5. b06:K2c5dZ, splitted lines accolated received: > b06:K2c5dZ:[ ] David Farrar > b06:K2c5dZ:[ ] Eric Dierker > b06:K2c5dZ:[ 1 >] Joop Teernstra > b06:K2c5dZ:[ ] Kent Crispin > b06:K2c5dZ:[ 2 >] Roberto Gaetano replaced by: > b06:K2c5dZ:[ ] David Farrar > b06:K2c5dZ:[ ] Eric Dierker > b06:K2c5dZ:[ 1 ] Joop Teernstra > b06:K2c5dZ:[ ] Kent Crispin > b06:K2c5dZ:[ 2 ] Roberto Gaetano
D. Eight (8) "x" adjustements:
Eight (8) received ballots were with only one candidate marked, not with "1" but with "x".
The Secretariat tends to consider these ballots valid, "x" replaced by "1" for results calculation.
1 b06:K16f3Z:[x] Roberto Gaetano 2 b06:K468eZ:[x] David Farrar 3 b06:K4f0dZ:[X] Joop Teernstra 4 b06:K8236Z:[x] Roberto Gaetano 5 b06:K8686Z:[x] Roberto Gaetano 6 b06:Ka996Z:[X] Joop Teernstra 7 b06:Kec3aZ:[x] David Farrar 8 b06:KfffbZ:[X] Roberto Gaetano
E. Full public record:
Ballot sent with choices b06:[ ] David Farrar b06:[ ] Eric Dierker b06:[ ] Joop Teernstra b06:[ ] Kent Crispin b06:[ ] Roberto Gaetano Electorate of 326 persons, casting one vote each Ballots received from 81 persons (sorted by arrival time) Susan Crawford Kendall Dawson Richard W. Kroon Bruce James Ronald Weikers Dave Geurs Camron Johnson Hartmut Richard Glaser Cindy Merry Erick Iriarte Annette Leung Rod Dixon David Johnson Shuo Lin Timothy Denton Michael Haffely Bret Fausett Scott Hollenbeck Kristal Preschern Janet Dagley Dagley Harald Tveit Alvestrand Alexander Svensson Oscar Robles Thomas Roessler Elisabeth Porteneuve Sloan Gaon Paul Stahura Sotiris Sotiropoulos Eric Weisberg Nestor Requeno Lee Lowery Jean-François C. (Jefsey) Morfin ken stubbs Meinrad Nell Peter de Blanc Marc Schneiders Jacek Duniec William X. Walsh David Ervin Earl Heather Matthew Enger Karl E. Peters Darryl G Lynch Jim Ayson Richard Lindsay Chris McElroy Charles Shaban Dany Vandromme Keith Gymer Michael Miller Babajide Afolabi Guy Millward Dirk Lorenz Chippu Abraham Giacomo Catenazzi Vladimir Afanasev Joop Teernstra Rita Kershaw Adam Peake Randel Hanes Gerald St. Amand Michaela Gerberich Michael F. McNulty Darrell Greenwood Chuck Gomes Joanna Lane Harold Burstyn Jonathan Weinberg Annie Renard Tobias Kleck David Farrar Gary Osbourne Anupam Chander Steven Heath Patrick Corliss Andrew McMeikan Rick H Wesson Ellen Rony Michael Froomkin Leah Gallegos Franchette Soriano ------------------------------------------------------------- Now selecting the first ------------------------------------------------------------- Casted votes (sorted by personal code) K16f3Z : 0,0,0,0,1, K1a8bZ : 0,0,0,0,1, K1af8Z : 1,5,4,3,2, K2132Z : 5,2,1,3,4, K22dcZ : 2,3,0,1,0, K23b5Z : 0,0,3,2,1, K247eZ : 0,0,0,1,2, K2580Z : 1,0,0,0,0, K26a7Z : 0,0,1,0,0, K28bdZ : 3,2,1,0,0, K2b02Z : 2,4,1,3,5, K2c5dZ : 0,0,1,0,2, K2dbcZ : 1,0,2,0,3, K3232Z : 0,2,1,0,0, K37e4Z : 0,0,0,0,0, K43adZ : 0,0,1,0,0, K43f5Z : 5,2,4,1,3, K468eZ : 1,0,0,0,0, K4ab9Z : 0,0,0,0,1, K4f0dZ : 0,0,1,0,0, K5150Z : 0,0,0,0,1, K54c9Z : 3,0,0,2,1, K54d1Z : 2,4,5,3,1, K57b5Z : 0,3,1,0,2, K57bfZ : 2,1,4,3,5, K69adZ : 0,0,0,2,1, K6bbdZ : 4,0,1,3,2, K6ca8Z : 1,0,0,0,2, K70d1Z : 0,0,0,2,1, K712eZ : 5,1,4,3,2, K7277Z : 1,2,5,0,0, K7577Z : 1,5,4,3,2, K75fcZ : 3,1,5,2,4, K7ab4Z : 0,0,0,2,1, K7b7eZ : 1,3,5,4,2, K7cd6Z : 2,0,4,3,1, K8186Z : 2,1,0,3,0, K8236Z : 0,0,0,0,1, K85faZ : 2,3,0,1,0, K8686Z : 0,0,0,0,1, K8812Z : 0,0,3,1,2, K8ed2Z : 0,0,2,0,1, K8eefZ : 1,2,3,0,0, K9082Z : 5,3,4,2,1, K9316Z : 3,5,1,4,2, K9359Z : 3,2,1,0,0, K96ddZ : 1,0,0,0,2, K9742Z : 0,3,0,2,1, K9ceeZ : 0,0,0,1,0, K9f3aZ : 0,1,0,0,0, Ka0f9Z : 2,0,1,0,0, Ka218Z : 1,3,2,5,4, Ka21dZ : 1,0,3,0,2, Ka3a3Z : 0,0,0,2,1, Ka996Z : 0,0,1,0,0, Kaa39Z : 0,3,1,0,2, Kab74Z : 0,3,2,0,1, KadbdZ : 0,0,0,0,1, Kb2f6Z : 0,0,1,0,2, Kb3ebZ : 0,2,0,3,1, Kb7c2Z : 0,0,0,1,2, Kbd0fZ : 0,0,1,0,0, Kc1eaZ : 2,4,1,0,3, Kc44dZ : 3,5,4,2,1, Kc6c0Z : 3,1,5,2,4, Kc6c9Z : 0,3,1,0,2, Kcf95Z : 2,0,0,3,1, Kd28eZ : 2,1,4,3,5, Kda05Z : 5,4,3,1,2, Kda43Z : 2,5,4,3,1, Kdb33Z : 2,0,4,3,1, Kdbf9Z : 1,0,0,0,2, Ke24bZ : 1,0,0,0,0, Ke496Z : 4,3,2,5,1, Ke8ccZ : 0,0,2,0,1, Ke96eZ : 2,0,3,0,1, Kec3aZ : 1,0,0,0,0, Kedd1Z : 4,2,3,5,1, Kf320Z : 0,0,0,2,1, Kf3a0Z : 2,4,3,1,5, KfffbZ : 0,0,0,0,1, Now 81 valid ballots Public results 81 BALLOTS => Majority = 41 Nb votes for Rank: 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 in %: 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 David Farrar 36, 15, 15, 7, 3, 5, 44, 19, 19, 9, 4, 6, Eric Dierker 44, 7, 9, 11, 5, 5, 54, 9, 11, 14, 6, 6, Joop Teernstra 32, 19, 6, 8, 11, 5, 40, 23, 7, 10, 14, 6, Kent Crispin 40, 9, 12, 15, 2, 3, 49, 11, 15, 19, 2, 4, Roberto Gaetano 21, 30, 19, 3, 4, 4, 26, 37, 23, 4, 5, 5, Total : 173, 80, 61, 44, 25, 22, (405) ROUND 1 STEP 1 : Roberto Gaetano has 30 rank 1 ballots he does not have the majority The lowest score is Eric Dierker with 7 rank 1 ballots Discarding Eric Dierker : K16f3Z : 0,x,0,0,1, 0,x,0,0,1, K1a8bZ : 0,x,0,0,1, 0,x,0,0,1, K1af8Z : 1,x,4,3,2, 1,x,4,3,2, K2132Z : 5,x,1,3,4, 4,x,1,2,3, K22dcZ : 2,x,0,1,0, 2,x,0,1,0, K23b5Z : 0,x,3,2,1, 0,x,3,2,1, K247eZ : 0,x,0,1,2, 0,x,0,1,2, K2580Z : 1,x,0,0,0, 1,x,0,0,0, K26a7Z : 0,x,1,0,0, 0,x,1,0,0, K28bdZ : 3,x,1,0,0, 2,x,1,0,0, K2b02Z : 2,x,1,3,5, 2,x,1,3,4, K2c5dZ : 0,x,1,0,2, 0,x,1,0,2, K2dbcZ : 1,x,2,0,3, 1,x,2,0,3, K3232Z : 0,x,1,0,0, 0,x,1,0,0, K37e4Z : 0,x,0,0,0, 0,x,0,0,0, Ballot discarded K43adZ : 0,x,1,0,0, 0,x,1,0,0, K43f5Z : 5,x,4,1,3, 4,x,3,1,2, K468eZ : 1,x,0,0,0, 1,x,0,0,0, K4ab9Z : 0,x,0,0,1, 0,x,0,0,1, K4f0dZ : 0,x,1,0,0, 0,x,1,0,0, K5150Z : 0,x,0,0,1, 0,x,0,0,1, K54c9Z : 3,x,0,2,1, 3,x,0,2,1, K54d1Z : 2,x,5,3,1, 2,x,4,3,1, K57b5Z : 0,x,1,0,2, 0,x,1,0,2, K57bfZ : 2,x,4,3,5, 1,x,3,2,4, K69adZ : 0,x,0,2,1, 0,x,0,2,1, K6bbdZ : 4,x,1,3,2, 4,x,1,3,2, K6ca8Z : 1,x,0,0,2, 1,x,0,0,2, K70d1Z : 0,x,0,2,1, 0,x,0,2,1, K712eZ : 5,x,4,3,2, 4,x,3,2,1, K7277Z : 1,x,5,0,0, 1,x,4,0,0, K7577Z : 1,x,4,3,2, 1,x,4,3,2, K75fcZ : 3,x,5,2,4, 2,x,4,1,3, K7ab4Z : 0,x,0,2,1, 0,x,0,2,1, K7b7eZ : 1,x,5,4,2, 1,x,4,3,2, K7cd6Z : 2,x,4,3,1, 2,x,4,3,1, K8186Z : 2,x,0,3,0, 1,x,0,2,0, K8236Z : 0,x,0,0,1, 0,x,0,0,1, K85faZ : 2,x,0,1,0, 2,x,0,1,0, K8686Z : 0,x,0,0,1, 0,x,0,0,1, K8812Z : 0,x,3,1,2, 0,x,3,1,2, K8ed2Z : 0,x,2,0,1, 0,x,2,0,1, K8eefZ : 1,x,3,0,0, 1,x,2,0,0, K9082Z : 5,x,4,2,1, 4,x,3,2,1, K9316Z : 3,x,1,4,2, 3,x,1,4,2, K9359Z : 3,x,1,0,0, 2,x,1,0,0, K96ddZ : 1,x,0,0,2, 1,x,0,0,2, K9742Z : 0,x,0,2,1, 0,x,0,2,1, K9ceeZ : 0,x,0,1,0, 0,x,0,1,0, K9f3aZ : 0,x,0,0,0, 0,x,0,0,0, Ballot discarded Ka0f9Z : 2,x,1,0,0, 2,x,1,0,0, Ka218Z : 1,x,2,5,4, 1,x,2,4,3, Ka21dZ : 1,x,3,0,2, 1,x,3,0,2, Ka3a3Z : 0,x,0,2,1, 0,x,0,2,1, Ka996Z : 0,x,1,0,0, 0,x,1,0,0, Kaa39Z : 0,x,1,0,2, 0,x,1,0,2, Kab74Z : 0,x,2,0,1, 0,x,2,0,1, KadbdZ : 0,x,0,0,1, 0,x,0,0,1, Kb2f6Z : 0,x,1,0,2, 0,x,1,0,2, Kb3ebZ : 0,x,0,3,1, 0,x,0,2,1, Kb7c2Z : 0,x,0,1,2, 0,x,0,1,2, Kbd0fZ : 0,x,1,0,0, 0,x,1,0,0, Kc1eaZ : 2,x,1,0,3, 2,x,1,0,3, Kc44dZ : 3,x,4,2,1, 3,x,4,2,1, Kc6c0Z : 3,x,5,2,4, 2,x,4,1,3, Kc6c9Z : 0,x,1,0,2, 0,x,1,0,2, Kcf95Z : 2,x,0,3,1, 2,x,0,3,1, Kd28eZ : 2,x,4,3,5, 1,x,3,2,4, Kda05Z : 5,x,3,1,2, 4,x,3,1,2, Kda43Z : 2,x,4,3,1, 2,x,4,3,1, Kdb33Z : 2,x,4,3,1, 2,x,4,3,1, Kdbf9Z : 1,x,0,0,2, 1,x,0,0,2, Ke24bZ : 1,x,0,0,0, 1,x,0,0,0, Ke496Z : 4,x,2,5,1, 3,x,2,4,1, Ke8ccZ : 0,x,2,0,1, 0,x,2,0,1, Ke96eZ : 2,x,3,0,1, 2,x,3,0,1, Kec3aZ : 1,x,0,0,0, 1,x,0,0,0, Kedd1Z : 4,x,3,5,1, 3,x,2,4,1, Kf320Z : 0,x,0,2,1, 0,x,0,2,1, Kf3a0Z : 2,x,3,1,5, 2,x,3,1,4, KfffbZ : 0,x,0,0,1, 0,x,0,0,1, Now 79 valid ballots Casted votes (sorted by personal code) K16f3Z : 0,x,0,0,1, K1a8bZ : 0,x,0,0,1, K1af8Z : 1,x,4,3,2, K2132Z : 4,x,1,2,3, K22dcZ : 2,x,0,1,0, K23b5Z : 0,x,3,2,1, K247eZ : 0,x,0,1,2, K2580Z : 1,x,0,0,0, K26a7Z : 0,x,1,0,0, K28bdZ : 2,x,1,0,0, K2b02Z : 2,x,1,3,4, K2c5dZ : 0,x,1,0,2, K2dbcZ : 1,x,2,0,3, K3232Z : 0,x,1,0,0, K43adZ : 0,x,1,0,0, K43f5Z : 4,x,3,1,2, K468eZ : 1,x,0,0,0, K4ab9Z : 0,x,0,0,1, K4f0dZ : 0,x,1,0,0, K5150Z : 0,x,0,0,1, K54c9Z : 3,x,0,2,1, K54d1Z : 2,x,4,3,1, K57b5Z : 0,x,1,0,2, K57bfZ : 1,x,3,2,4, K69adZ : 0,x,0,2,1, K6bbdZ : 4,x,1,3,2, K6ca8Z : 1,x,0,0,2, K70d1Z : 0,x,0,2,1, K712eZ : 4,x,3,2,1, K7277Z : 1,x,4,0,0, K7577Z : 1,x,4,3,2, K75fcZ : 2,x,4,1,3, K7ab4Z : 0,x,0,2,1, K7b7eZ : 1,x,4,3,2, K7cd6Z : 2,x,4,3,1, K8186Z : 1,x,0,2,0, K8236Z : 0,x,0,0,1, K85faZ : 2,x,0,1,0, K8686Z : 0,x,0,0,1, K8812Z : 0,x,3,1,2, K8ed2Z : 0,x,2,0,1, K8eefZ : 1,x,2,0,0, K9082Z : 4,x,3,2,1, K9316Z : 3,x,1,4,2, K9359Z : 2,x,1,0,0, K96ddZ : 1,x,0,0,2, K9742Z : 0,x,0,2,1, K9ceeZ : 0,x,0,1,0, Ka0f9Z : 2,x,1,0,0, Ka218Z : 1,x,2,4,3, Ka21dZ : 1,x,3,0,2, Ka3a3Z : 0,x,0,2,1, Ka996Z : 0,x,1,0,0, Kaa39Z : 0,x,1,0,2, Kab74Z : 0,x,2,0,1, KadbdZ : 0,x,0,0,1, Kb2f6Z : 0,x,1,0,2, Kb3ebZ : 0,x,0,2,1, Kb7c2Z : 0,x,0,1,2, Kbd0fZ : 0,x,1,0,0, Kc1eaZ : 2,x,1,0,3, Kc44dZ : 3,x,4,2,1, Kc6c0Z : 2,x,4,1,3, Kc6c9Z : 0,x,1,0,2, Kcf95Z : 2,x,0,3,1, Kd28eZ : 1,x,3,2,4, Kda05Z : 4,x,3,1,2, Kda43Z : 2,x,4,3,1, Kdb33Z : 2,x,4,3,1, Kdbf9Z : 1,x,0,0,2, Ke24bZ : 1,x,0,0,0, Ke496Z : 3,x,2,4,1, Ke8ccZ : 0,x,2,0,1, Ke96eZ : 2,x,3,0,1, Kec3aZ : 1,x,0,0,0, Kedd1Z : 3,x,2,4,1, Kf320Z : 0,x,0,2,1, Kf3a0Z : 2,x,3,1,4, KfffbZ : 0,x,0,0,1, Now 79 valid ballots Public results 79 BALLOTS => Majority = 40 Nb votes for Rank: 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 in %: 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 David Farrar 34, 18, 16, 5, 6, 0, 43, 23, 20, 6, 8, 0, Discarded 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, Joop Teernstra 30, 19, 8, 11, 11, 0, 38, 24, 10, 14, 14, 0, Kent Crispin 38, 11, 16, 10, 4, 0, 48, 14, 20, 13, 5, 0, Roberto Gaetano 19, 31, 19, 6, 4, 0, 24, 39, 24, 8, 5, 0, Total : 121, 79, 59, 32, 25, 0, (316) ROUND 1 STEP 2 : Roberto Gaetano has 31 rank 1 ballots he does not have the majority The lowest score is Kent Crispin with 11 rank 1 ballots Discarding Kent Crispin : K16f3Z : 0,x,0,x,1, 0,x,0,x,1, K1a8bZ : 0,x,0,x,1, 0,x,0,x,1, K1af8Z : 1,x,4,x,2, 1,x,3,x,2, K2132Z : 4,x,1,x,3, 3,x,1,x,2, K22dcZ : 2,x,0,x,0, 1,x,0,x,0, K23b5Z : 0,x,3,x,1, 0,x,2,x,1, K247eZ : 0,x,0,x,2, 0,x,0,x,1, K2580Z : 1,x,0,x,0, 1,x,0,x,0, K26a7Z : 0,x,1,x,0, 0,x,1,x,0, K28bdZ : 2,x,1,x,0, 2,x,1,x,0, K2b02Z : 2,x,1,x,4, 2,x,1,x,3, K2c5dZ : 0,x,1,x,2, 0,x,1,x,2, K2dbcZ : 1,x,2,x,3, 1,x,2,x,3, K3232Z : 0,x,1,x,0, 0,x,1,x,0, K43adZ : 0,x,1,x,0, 0,x,1,x,0, K43f5Z : 4,x,3,x,2, 3,x,2,x,1, K468eZ : 1,x,0,x,0, 1,x,0,x,0, K4ab9Z : 0,x,0,x,1, 0,x,0,x,1, K4f0dZ : 0,x,1,x,0, 0,x,1,x,0, K5150Z : 0,x,0,x,1, 0,x,0,x,1, K54c9Z : 3,x,0,x,1, 2,x,0,x,1, K54d1Z : 2,x,4,x,1, 2,x,3,x,1, K57b5Z : 0,x,1,x,2, 0,x,1,x,2, K57bfZ : 1,x,3,x,4, 1,x,2,x,3, K69adZ : 0,x,0,x,1, 0,x,0,x,1, K6bbdZ : 4,x,1,x,2, 3,x,1,x,2, K6ca8Z : 1,x,0,x,2, 1,x,0,x,2, K70d1Z : 0,x,0,x,1, 0,x,0,x,1, K712eZ : 4,x,3,x,1, 3,x,2,x,1, K7277Z : 1,x,4,x,0, 1,x,3,x,0, K7577Z : 1,x,4,x,2, 1,x,3,x,2, K75fcZ : 2,x,4,x,3, 1,x,3,x,2, K7ab4Z : 0,x,0,x,1, 0,x,0,x,1, K7b7eZ : 1,x,4,x,2, 1,x,3,x,2, K7cd6Z : 2,x,4,x,1, 2,x,3,x,1, K8186Z : 1,x,0,x,0, 1,x,0,x,0, K8236Z : 0,x,0,x,1, 0,x,0,x,1, K85faZ : 2,x,0,x,0, 1,x,0,x,0, K8686Z : 0,x,0,x,1, 0,x,0,x,1, K8812Z : 0,x,3,x,2, 0,x,2,x,1, K8ed2Z : 0,x,2,x,1, 0,x,2,x,1, K8eefZ : 1,x,2,x,0, 1,x,2,x,0, K9082Z : 4,x,3,x,1, 3,x,2,x,1, K9316Z : 3,x,1,x,2, 3,x,1,x,2, K9359Z : 2,x,1,x,0, 2,x,1,x,0, K96ddZ : 1,x,0,x,2, 1,x,0,x,2, K9742Z : 0,x,0,x,1, 0,x,0,x,1, K9ceeZ : 0,x,0,x,0, 0,x,0,x,0, Ballot discarded Ka0f9Z : 2,x,1,x,0, 2,x,1,x,0, Ka218Z : 1,x,2,x,3, 1,x,2,x,3, Ka21dZ : 1,x,3,x,2, 1,x,3,x,2, Ka3a3Z : 0,x,0,x,1, 0,x,0,x,1, Ka996Z : 0,x,1,x,0, 0,x,1,x,0, Kaa39Z : 0,x,1,x,2, 0,x,1,x,2, Kab74Z : 0,x,2,x,1, 0,x,2,x,1, KadbdZ : 0,x,0,x,1, 0,x,0,x,1, Kb2f6Z : 0,x,1,x,2, 0,x,1,x,2, Kb3ebZ : 0,x,0,x,1, 0,x,0,x,1, Kb7c2Z : 0,x,0,x,2, 0,x,0,x,1, Kbd0fZ : 0,x,1,x,0, 0,x,1,x,0, Kc1eaZ : 2,x,1,x,3, 2,x,1,x,3, Kc44dZ : 3,x,4,x,1, 2,x,3,x,1, Kc6c0Z : 2,x,4,x,3, 1,x,3,x,2, Kc6c9Z : 0,x,1,x,2, 0,x,1,x,2, Kcf95Z : 2,x,0,x,1, 2,x,0,x,1, Kd28eZ : 1,x,3,x,4, 1,x,2,x,3, Kda05Z : 4,x,3,x,2, 3,x,2,x,1, Kda43Z : 2,x,4,x,1, 2,x,3,x,1, Kdb33Z : 2,x,4,x,1, 2,x,3,x,1, Kdbf9Z : 1,x,0,x,2, 1,x,0,x,2, Ke24bZ : 1,x,0,x,0, 1,x,0,x,0, Ke496Z : 3,x,2,x,1, 3,x,2,x,1, Ke8ccZ : 0,x,2,x,1, 0,x,2,x,1, Ke96eZ : 2,x,3,x,1, 2,x,3,x,1, Kec3aZ : 1,x,0,x,0, 1,x,0,x,0, Kedd1Z : 3,x,2,x,1, 3,x,2,x,1, Kf320Z : 0,x,0,x,1, 0,x,0,x,1, Kf3a0Z : 2,x,3,x,4, 1,x,2,x,3, KfffbZ : 0,x,0,x,1, 0,x,0,x,1, Now 78 valid ballots Casted votes (sorted by personal code) K16f3Z : 0,x,0,x,1, K1a8bZ : 0,x,0,x,1, K1af8Z : 1,x,3,x,2, K2132Z : 3,x,1,x,2, K22dcZ : 1,x,0,x,0, K23b5Z : 0,x,2,x,1, K247eZ : 0,x,0,x,1, K2580Z : 1,x,0,x,0, K26a7Z : 0,x,1,x,0, K28bdZ : 2,x,1,x,0, K2b02Z : 2,x,1,x,3, K2c5dZ : 0,x,1,x,2, K2dbcZ : 1,x,2,x,3, K3232Z : 0,x,1,x,0, K43adZ : 0,x,1,x,0, K43f5Z : 3,x,2,x,1, K468eZ : 1,x,0,x,0, K4ab9Z : 0,x,0,x,1, K4f0dZ : 0,x,1,x,0, K5150Z : 0,x,0,x,1, K54c9Z : 2,x,0,x,1, K54d1Z : 2,x,3,x,1, K57b5Z : 0,x,1,x,2, K57bfZ : 1,x,2,x,3, K69adZ : 0,x,0,x,1, K6bbdZ : 3,x,1,x,2, K6ca8Z : 1,x,0,x,2, K70d1Z : 0,x,0,x,1, K712eZ : 3,x,2,x,1, K7277Z : 1,x,3,x,0, K7577Z : 1,x,3,x,2, K75fcZ : 1,x,3,x,2, K7ab4Z : 0,x,0,x,1, K7b7eZ : 1,x,3,x,2, K7cd6Z : 2,x,3,x,1, K8186Z : 1,x,0,x,0, K8236Z : 0,x,0,x,1, K85faZ : 1,x,0,x,0, K8686Z : 0,x,0,x,1, K8812Z : 0,x,2,x,1, K8ed2Z : 0,x,2,x,1, K8eefZ : 1,x,2,x,0, K9082Z : 3,x,2,x,1, K9316Z : 3,x,1,x,2, K9359Z : 2,x,1,x,0, K96ddZ : 1,x,0,x,2, K9742Z : 0,x,0,x,1, Ka0f9Z : 2,x,1,x,0, Ka218Z : 1,x,2,x,3, Ka21dZ : 1,x,3,x,2, Ka3a3Z : 0,x,0,x,1, Ka996Z : 0,x,1,x,0, Kaa39Z : 0,x,1,x,2, Kab74Z : 0,x,2,x,1, KadbdZ : 0,x,0,x,1, Kb2f6Z : 0,x,1,x,2, Kb3ebZ : 0,x,0,x,1, Kb7c2Z : 0,x,0,x,1, Kbd0fZ : 0,x,1,x,0, Kc1eaZ : 2,x,1,x,3, Kc44dZ : 2,x,3,x,1, Kc6c0Z : 1,x,3,x,2, Kc6c9Z : 0,x,1,x,2, Kcf95Z : 2,x,0,x,1, Kd28eZ : 1,x,2,x,3, Kda05Z : 3,x,2,x,1, Kda43Z : 2,x,3,x,1, Kdb33Z : 2,x,3,x,1, Kdbf9Z : 1,x,0,x,2, Ke24bZ : 1,x,0,x,0, Ke496Z : 3,x,2,x,1, Ke8ccZ : 0,x,2,x,1, Ke96eZ : 2,x,3,x,1, Kec3aZ : 1,x,0,x,0, Kedd1Z : 3,x,2,x,1, Kf320Z : 0,x,0,x,1, Kf3a0Z : 1,x,2,x,3, KfffbZ : 0,x,0,x,1, Now 78 valid ballots Public results 78 BALLOTS => Majority = 40 Nb votes for Rank: 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 in %: 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 David Farrar 33, 23, 13, 9, 0, 0, 42, 29, 17, 12, 0, 0, Discarded 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, Joop Teernstra 29, 19, 17, 13, 0, 0, 37, 24, 22, 17, 0, 0, Discarded 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, Roberto Gaetano 18, 36, 17, 7, 0, 0, 23, 46, 22, 9, 0, 0, Total : 80, 78, 47, 29, 0, 0, (234) ROUND 1 STEP 3 : Roberto Gaetano has 36 rank 1 ballots he does not have the majority The lowest score is Joop Teernstra with 19 rank 1 ballots Discarding Joop Teernstra : K16f3Z : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, K1a8bZ : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, K1af8Z : 1,x,x,x,2, 1,x,x,x,2, K2132Z : 3,x,x,x,2, 2,x,x,x,1, K22dcZ : 1,x,x,x,0, 1,x,x,x,0, K23b5Z : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, K247eZ : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, K2580Z : 1,x,x,x,0, 1,x,x,x,0, K26a7Z : 0,x,x,x,0, 0,x,x,x,0, Ballot discarded K28bdZ : 2,x,x,x,0, 1,x,x,x,0, K2b02Z : 2,x,x,x,3, 1,x,x,x,2, K2c5dZ : 0,x,x,x,2, 0,x,x,x,1, K2dbcZ : 1,x,x,x,3, 1,x,x,x,2, K3232Z : 0,x,x,x,0, 0,x,x,x,0, Ballot discarded K43adZ : 0,x,x,x,0, 0,x,x,x,0, Ballot discarded K43f5Z : 3,x,x,x,1, 2,x,x,x,1, K468eZ : 1,x,x,x,0, 1,x,x,x,0, K4ab9Z : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, K4f0dZ : 0,x,x,x,0, 0,x,x,x,0, Ballot discarded K5150Z : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, K54c9Z : 2,x,x,x,1, 2,x,x,x,1, K54d1Z : 2,x,x,x,1, 2,x,x,x,1, K57b5Z : 0,x,x,x,2, 0,x,x,x,1, K57bfZ : 1,x,x,x,3, 1,x,x,x,2, K69adZ : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, K6bbdZ : 3,x,x,x,2, 2,x,x,x,1, K6ca8Z : 1,x,x,x,2, 1,x,x,x,2, K70d1Z : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, K712eZ : 3,x,x,x,1, 2,x,x,x,1, K7277Z : 1,x,x,x,0, 1,x,x,x,0, K7577Z : 1,x,x,x,2, 1,x,x,x,2, K75fcZ : 1,x,x,x,2, 1,x,x,x,2, K7ab4Z : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, K7b7eZ : 1,x,x,x,2, 1,x,x,x,2, K7cd6Z : 2,x,x,x,1, 2,x,x,x,1, K8186Z : 1,x,x,x,0, 1,x,x,x,0, K8236Z : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, K85faZ : 1,x,x,x,0, 1,x,x,x,0, K8686Z : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, K8812Z : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, K8ed2Z : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, K8eefZ : 1,x,x,x,0, 1,x,x,x,0, K9082Z : 3,x,x,x,1, 2,x,x,x,1, K9316Z : 3,x,x,x,2, 2,x,x,x,1, K9359Z : 2,x,x,x,0, 1,x,x,x,0, K96ddZ : 1,x,x,x,2, 1,x,x,x,2, K9742Z : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, Ka0f9Z : 2,x,x,x,0, 1,x,x,x,0, Ka218Z : 1,x,x,x,3, 1,x,x,x,2, Ka21dZ : 1,x,x,x,2, 1,x,x,x,2, Ka3a3Z : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, Ka996Z : 0,x,x,x,0, 0,x,x,x,0, Ballot discarded Kaa39Z : 0,x,x,x,2, 0,x,x,x,1, Kab74Z : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, KadbdZ : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, Kb2f6Z : 0,x,x,x,2, 0,x,x,x,1, Kb3ebZ : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, Kb7c2Z : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, Kbd0fZ : 0,x,x,x,0, 0,x,x,x,0, Ballot discarded Kc1eaZ : 2,x,x,x,3, 1,x,x,x,2, Kc44dZ : 2,x,x,x,1, 2,x,x,x,1, Kc6c0Z : 1,x,x,x,2, 1,x,x,x,2, Kc6c9Z : 0,x,x,x,2, 0,x,x,x,1, Kcf95Z : 2,x,x,x,1, 2,x,x,x,1, Kd28eZ : 1,x,x,x,3, 1,x,x,x,2, Kda05Z : 3,x,x,x,1, 2,x,x,x,1, Kda43Z : 2,x,x,x,1, 2,x,x,x,1, Kdb33Z : 2,x,x,x,1, 2,x,x,x,1, Kdbf9Z : 1,x,x,x,2, 1,x,x,x,2, Ke24bZ : 1,x,x,x,0, 1,x,x,x,0, Ke496Z : 3,x,x,x,1, 2,x,x,x,1, Ke8ccZ : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, Ke96eZ : 2,x,x,x,1, 2,x,x,x,1, Kec3aZ : 1,x,x,x,0, 1,x,x,x,0, Kedd1Z : 3,x,x,x,1, 2,x,x,x,1, Kf320Z : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, Kf3a0Z : 1,x,x,x,3, 1,x,x,x,2, KfffbZ : 0,x,x,x,1, 0,x,x,x,1, Now 72 valid ballots Casted votes (sorted by personal code) K16f3Z : 0,x,x,x,1, K1a8bZ : 0,x,x,x,1, K1af8Z : 1,x,x,x,2, K2132Z : 2,x,x,x,1, K22dcZ : 1,x,x,x,0, K23b5Z : 0,x,x,x,1, K247eZ : 0,x,x,x,1, K2580Z : 1,x,x,x,0, K28bdZ : 1,x,x,x,0, K2b02Z : 1,x,x,x,2, K2c5dZ : 0,x,x,x,1, K2dbcZ : 1,x,x,x,2, K43f5Z : 2,x,x,x,1, K468eZ : 1,x,x,x,0, K4ab9Z : 0,x,x,x,1, K5150Z : 0,x,x,x,1, K54c9Z : 2,x,x,x,1, K54d1Z : 2,x,x,x,1, K57b5Z : 0,x,x,x,1, K57bfZ : 1,x,x,x,2, K69adZ : 0,x,x,x,1, K6bbdZ : 2,x,x,x,1, K6ca8Z : 1,x,x,x,2, K70d1Z : 0,x,x,x,1, K712eZ : 2,x,x,x,1, K7277Z : 1,x,x,x,0, K7577Z : 1,x,x,x,2, K75fcZ : 1,x,x,x,2, K7ab4Z : 0,x,x,x,1, K7b7eZ : 1,x,x,x,2, K7cd6Z : 2,x,x,x,1, K8186Z : 1,x,x,x,0, K8236Z : 0,x,x,x,1, K85faZ : 1,x,x,x,0, K8686Z : 0,x,x,x,1, K8812Z : 0,x,x,x,1, K8ed2Z : 0,x,x,x,1, K8eefZ : 1,x,x,x,0, K9082Z : 2,x,x,x,1, K9316Z : 2,x,x,x,1, K9359Z : 1,x,x,x,0, K96ddZ : 1,x,x,x,2, K9742Z : 0,x,x,x,1, Ka0f9Z : 1,x,x,x,0, Ka218Z : 1,x,x,x,2, Ka21dZ : 1,x,x,x,2, Ka3a3Z : 0,x,x,x,1, Kaa39Z : 0,x,x,x,1, Kab74Z : 0,x,x,x,1, KadbdZ : 0,x,x,x,1, Kb2f6Z : 0,x,x,x,1, Kb3ebZ : 0,x,x,x,1, Kb7c2Z : 0,x,x,x,1, Kc1eaZ : 1,x,x,x,2, Kc44dZ : 2,x,x,x,1, Kc6c0Z : 1,x,x,x,2, Kc6c9Z : 0,x,x,x,1, Kcf95Z : 2,x,x,x,1, Kd28eZ : 1,x,x,x,2, Kda05Z : 2,x,x,x,1, Kda43Z : 2,x,x,x,1, Kdb33Z : 2,x,x,x,1, Kdbf9Z : 1,x,x,x,2, Ke24bZ : 1,x,x,x,0, Ke496Z : 2,x,x,x,1, Ke8ccZ : 0,x,x,x,1, Ke96eZ : 2,x,x,x,1, Kec3aZ : 1,x,x,x,0, Kedd1Z : 2,x,x,x,1, Kf320Z : 0,x,x,x,1, Kf3a0Z : 1,x,x,x,2, KfffbZ : 0,x,x,x,1, Now 72 valid ballots Public results 72 BALLOTS => Majority = 37 Nb votes for Rank: 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 in %: 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 David Farrar 27, 28, 17, 0, 0, 0, 38, 39, 24, 0, 0, 0, Discarded 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, Discarded 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, Discarded 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, Roberto Gaetano 12, 44, 16, 0, 0, 0, 17, 61, 22, 0, 0, 0, Total : 39, 72, 33, 0, 0, 0, (144) ROUND 1 STEP 4 : Roberto Gaetano has 44 rank 1 ballots he has the majority : he is selected -- End
Information from: |
© DNSO Secretariat |