ICANN/DNSO
Full record of vote by the GA to designate its representative to the Names Council Transfer Task Force, January 2002 |
Friday 11 January 2002, at 16:00 UTC, 17:00 CET (Paris).
Re: b10
Vote by the GA to designate its representative to the Names Council Transfer Task Force
cf. http://www.dnso.org/dnso/notes/2001.DNSO-GA-TransferTF.html
The vote was conducted by the DNSO Secretariat using Instant Runoff Vote according to the Election Rules adopted by the GA and published in: http://www.dnso.org/dnso/notes/2001.GA-chair-election-rules-v0.2.html.
The members to the Watchdog Committee in the 2001/2002 election are:
The time for the vote was:
Begins: Thursday 3 January 2002, 16:00 UTC, 17:00 CET (Paris),
Ends: Thursday 10 January 2002, 15:00 UTC, 16:00 CET (Paris)
The list gavote@dnso.org was closed on 10 January at 15:15 UTC (16:15 Paris). Since then all e-mails sent to that list return to the sender with a Delivery Report "User unknown".
A. The final result:
Dan Steinberg is elected
B. Information about ballots received:
Number of ballots received: 114
Two (2) ballots empty:
1 b10:K6182Z
2 b10:K61e4Z
which adds to number of valid ballots, and increases majority requirement in the first step.
Besides ballots we received nineteen (19) Delivery-Reports:
1 b10:K52a0Z
2 b10:K55ffZ
3 b10:K76fdZ
4 b10:K3398Z
5 b10:K3c00Z
6 b10:Kf98dZ
7 b10:K6aaaZ
8 b10:Kdb0fZ
9 b10:K8429Z
10 b10:Kd596Z
11 b10:Kbf80Z
12 b10:K936aZ
13 b10:Kb5f8Z
14 b10:Kae19Z
15 b10:Kbe0aZ
16 b10:K177fZ
17 b10:Ke3a6Z
18 b10:Ka925Z
19 b10:K13d8Z
Three (3) voters sent multiple ballots, the last overrides the others:
1. b10:Kb24dZ
2. b10:K7b6cZ
3. b10:K5f3dZ
C. Adjustements:
HTML formats were trashed when appropriate.
D. Nine (9) "x" adjustements:
Nine (9) received ballots were with only one candidate marked, not with "1" but with "x".
The Secretariat tends to consider these ballots valid, "x" replaced by "1" for results calculation.
1 b10:Kd6eeZ:[X] Dan Steinberg
2 b10:Kf88cZ:[x] Dan Steinberg
3 b10:Kc226Z:[x] Dan Steinberg
4 b10:Kd278Z:[X] Dan Steinberg
5 b10:K120eZ:[x] Dan Steinberg
6 b10:K5a5eZ:[x] Dan Steinberg
7 b10:K276cZ:[x] Dan Steinberg
8 b10:Ke8f8Z:[x] Dan Steinberg
9 b10:K8319Z:[x] Jeffrey A Williams
E. Full public record:
Ballot sent with choices
b10:[ ] Dan Steinberg
b10:[ ] Eric Dierker
b10:[ ] Jeffrey A Williams
Electorate of 456 persons, casting one vote each
Ballots received from 114 persons (sorted by arrival time)
1 Elisabeth Porteneuve
2 Dave Geurs
3 Archassal Pierre
4 Kendall Dawson
5 Susan Crawford
6 Dany Vandromme
7 Karl E. Peters
8 Keith Gymer
9 Theo Peters
10 Robert F. Connelly
11 Christine Russo
12 Timothy Denton
13 Rod Dixon
14 Matthew Enger
15 Roberto Gaetano
16 Michel Guillou
17 Glen de Saint Gery
18 Guenter Meyer
19 Kent Crispin
20 Michael Froomkin
21 Paul Svensson
22 Harald Tveit Alvestrand
23 Olivier Guillard
24 Roeland Meyer
25 Serge Guissani
26 Bruce James
27 David Johnson
28 Craig Larsen
29 Alexander Svensson
30 Jeanette Hofmann
31 Kristal Preschern
32 Sloan Gaon
33 Thomas Roessler
34 Rick H Wesson
35 Jacques Roelens
36 Oscar Robles
37 Ross Wm. Rader
38 Ken Stubbs
39 Jean-Christophe Loubet del Bayle
40 Hugh Blair
41 Chuck Gomes
42 Alberto Pellizzari
43 Jean Marc Levy Dreyfus
44 Vincent Deveze
45 Karen Dredske
46 Adrian Richter
47 Charles Lane
48 Stéphane Reuille
49 Joe Gluza
50 Patrick Greenwell
51 Frederic Wilf
52 Gary Osbourne
53 Leon Kappelman
54 Jessica Westbrook
55 Joe Kelsey
56 Ellen Rony
57 Sandy Harris
58 Jan Hoogendoorn
59 Joseph Farley
60 Richard W. Kroon
61 Bret Fausett
62 Joop Teernstra
63 David Farrar
64 Michael Haffely
65 Joseph Friedman
66 Vincent Fournols
67 Scott Hollenbeck
68 Brad Copeland
69 David Keegel
70 Hartmut Richard Glaser
71 Ramesh Kumar Nadarajah
72 Jonathan Weinberg
73 Jan Gora
74 Leah Gallegos
75 Nestor Requeno
76 Matthew Pemble
77 Patrick Corliss
78 Emmanuelle Bobin
79 Randel Hanes
80 Clifford Paravicini
81 Meinrad Nell
82 Jose Enrique Díaz Jolly
83 Michael F. McNulty
84 Seth Goodman
85 Miriam Sapiro
86 Dominique Dhoosche
87 Marilyn Cade
88 Dennis Schaefer
89 Jean-François C. (Jefsey) Morfin
90 Sam Michel Cembalo
91 Joseph Lee
92 Kilian Wahl
93 Dirk Lorenz
94 Young-Eum Lee
95 Sotiris Sotiropoulos
96 Rita Kershaw
97 Steffen Goewe
98 Michael Miller
99 Charles-Henri Boeringer
100 Tony Holmes
101 Jeffrey Williams
102 Ron Andruff
103 Ken Stoen
104 Steven Heath
105 Bradley D. Thornton
106 Adam Peake
107 Karim Bourenane
108 Gerard Guerin
109 Annie Renard
110 Elana Broitman
111 Earl Heather
112 John C Lewis
113 Steve Metalitz
114 Gerald St. Amand
Casted votes (sorted by personal code)
1 K10a3Z : 0,2,1,
2 K120eZ : 1,0,0,
3 K177aZ : 1,0,0,
4 K1f59Z : 0,1,0,
5 K1f5bZ : 2,1,0,
6 K211bZ : 1,0,0,
7 K21c2Z : 1,2,3,
8 K2478Z : 1,0,0,
9 K24f6Z : 1,0,0,
10 K24f9Z : 1,0,0,
11 K2528Z : 2,1,3,
12 K2616Z : 1,0,0,
13 K2759Z : 1,0,0,
14 K276cZ : 1,0,0,
15 K288eZ : 1,2,3,
16 K2942Z : 1,0,0,
17 K2a38Z : 3,2,1,
18 K2bc4Z : 0,1,2,
19 K2bf1Z : 2,3,1,
20 K2db4Z : 1,0,0,
21 K3192Z : 2,1,3,
22 K31d2Z : 3,2,1,
23 K32e2Z : 1,0,0,
24 K33f0Z : 1,2,0,
25 K343dZ : 1,0,0,
26 K348cZ : 1,2,0,
27 K352bZ : 1,2,0,
28 K35bbZ : 1,2,3,
29 K38abZ : 1,0,0,
30 K3c96Z : 3,1,2,
31 K3e58Z : 1,0,0,
32 K4454Z : 1,0,0,
33 K4496Z : 2,3,1,
34 K4681Z : 1,0,0,
35 K4a8eZ : 3,2,1,
36 K4b69Z : 1,3,2,
37 K4c70Z : 1,0,0,
38 K5066Z : 2,1,3,
39 K518eZ : 1,0,0,
40 K5213Z : 2,1,3,
41 K5811Z : 2,3,1,
42 K5a5eZ : 1,0,0,
43 K5ab8Z : 1,0,0,
44 K5f3dZ : 1,2,0,
45 K6182Z : 0,0,0,
46 K61a8Z : 1,0,0,
47 K61e4Z : 0,0,0,
48 K62b4Z : 0,2,1,
49 K64f1Z : 1,0,0,
50 K67f8Z : 2,1,3,
51 K6973Z : 1,0,0,
52 K69ecZ : 1,3,2,
53 K7031Z : 1,0,0,
54 K7330Z : 1,2,3,
55 K7606Z : 3,1,2,
56 K7b6cZ : 1,0,2,
57 K8319Z : 0,0,1,
58 K84fcZ : 2,0,1,
59 K8832Z : 1,0,0,
60 K8e35Z : 1,0,0,
61 K8f95Z : 1,0,0,
62 K8fd7Z : 1,0,0,
63 K95e0Z : 2,3,1,
64 K98dbZ : 2,1,0,
65 K9922Z : 1,2,0,
66 K995eZ : 1,0,0,
67 K9c3fZ : 0,1,0,
68 K9c6eZ : 2,1,3,
69 K9e83Z : 2,1,3,
70 Ka457Z : 1,0,0,
71 Ka677Z : 0,0,1,
72 Ka6dcZ : 2,0,1,
73 Ka74dZ : 1,0,0,
74 Ka754Z : 3,1,2,
75 KacffZ : 1,3,2,
76 Kad59Z : 1,2,3,
77 Kae7cZ : 1,0,0,
78 Kafa0Z : 2,1,3,
79 KaffeZ : 2,3,1,
80 Kb24dZ : 1,0,0,
81 Kb36cZ : 3,2,1,
82 Kb418Z : 1,0,0,
83 Kb420Z : 1,0,0,
84 Kb6bfZ : 0,2,1,
85 Kb86aZ : 1,3,2,
86 Kbcb3Z : 1,3,2,
87 Kbd83Z : 3,1,2,
88 Kc19fZ : 1,2,0,
89 Kc226Z : 1,0,0,
90 Kc3d0Z : 1,0,0,
91 Kc55bZ : 1,0,0,
92 Kc81cZ : 1,3,2,
93 Kc8c9Z : 1,0,0,
94 KcbbdZ : 1,0,0,
95 Kd1faZ : 1,0,0,
96 Kd278Z : 1,0,0,
97 Kd6eeZ : 1,0,0,
98 Kd848Z : 1,0,0,
99 Kd86aZ : 3,1,2,
100 Kda9bZ : 3,2,1,
101 KdabeZ : 1,2,3,
102 Kdb71Z : 1,0,0,
103 Kdc37Z : 0,1,0,
104 Kdc66Z : 3,1,2,
105 KdfacZ : 0,1,0,
106 Ke6a9Z : 2,1,3,
107 Ke8f8Z : 1,0,0,
108 Ke968Z : 1,2,3,
109 Kea61Z : 1,2,3,
110 Kea83Z : 2,1,3,
111 KeaabZ : 3,2,1,
112 Kf88cZ : 1,0,0,
113 KfbccZ : 1,0,0,
114 Kfc6dZ : 1,2,0,
Now 114 valid ballots
Public results
114 BALLOTS => Majority = 58
Nb votes for Rank : 0, 1, 2, 3 in % : 0, 1, 2, 3
Dan Steinberg 12, 71, 19, 12, 11, 62, 17, 11,
Eric Dierker 56, 23, 24, 11, 49, 20, 21, 10,
Jeffrey A Williams 64, 18, 14, 18, 56, 16, 12, 16,
Total : 132,112, 57, 41, (342)
ROUND 1 STEP 1 : Dan Steinberg has 71 rank 1 ballots
he has the majority : he is selected
--
End
| Information from: |
© DNSO Secretariat |