RE: additional drafts for dnso

["Siegfried Langenbach" <svl@nrw.net>]

On 27 Jan 99, at 15:53, Roberto Gaetano wrote:

Hallo Roberto,
I did post it first on discuss, did not see anything, probably not on the list.
then I postet it to participants :-)
as I see it they are even not similar, I am creating  mess...
siegfried

> Stef,
> 
> Just for curiosity, why did you answer Siegfried's post on
> discuss@dnso.org on ORSC+participants@dnso.org? ;>)
> 
> Roberto
> 
> 
> > -----Original Message-----
> > From:	Einar Stefferud [SMTP:Stef@nma.com]
> > Sent:	26 January 1999 22:27
> > To:	Siegfried Langenbach
> > Cc:	participants@dnso.org; domain-policy@open-rsc.org
> > Subject:	Re: additional drafts for dnso 
> > 
> > For whatever it is worth, ORSC will work on incorporating ideas from the
> > CENTR and AIP drafts into the composite ORSC MELDED DRAFT.
> > 
> > Plus any useful ideas that will come from the ConfCall of today.
> > 
> > Cheers...\Stef
> > 
> > From your message Tue, 26 Jan 1999 13:29:40 +0100:
> > }
> > }
> > }Hallo,
> > }
> > }after having time (and some discussions with others) to think I have
> > }some reflections on the washington meeting of jan 22.
> > }
> > }I am a bit concerned about CENTR presenting an own, separate approach.
> > }
> > }after enwrapping the nice things these draft has, I see here mainly the
> > }intention to give registrars and registries the power of dnso. As I
> > }believe that names are common good, its hard for me to accept these
> > }position (we should also remember that isp=B4s and registrars are to a
> > gr=
> > }eat
> > }extend similar, a problem which already exists in the mty-draft).
> > }
> > }more important is the fact that CENTR, not achieving their goals in the
> > }common meetings in negotiations with the other parties, is now
> > }splitting the process. that is a bad move and could result in others
> > }doing the
> > same.
> > }that is leading to nowhere.
> > }
> > }I recognize that there are parties who prefer a non-effective dnso, I
> > }would be sorry to see CENTR in that corner.
> > }
> > }siegfried
> > }
> > }
>