Re: [wg-c] Please Explain "No on 1, Yes on 2"

["Milton Mueller" <mueller@syr.edu>]

----- Original Message -----
From: "Philip Sheppard"

> Problem1:
> This is to closely linked with the WG C report proposition that "initial
> rollout" means 6-10. As many on this list agree, charters work when there
> are many of them.

We do agree, but I thought we also agreed that any progression from "0" to
"many" must at some point pass through "6-10"

>
> Problem 2.
> As Keith Gymer wrote "open" TLDs may mean undifferentiated which returns
us
> to the argument over what constitutes strong competition to dot com -
> imitation or value added.

Eh? If "open" means "undifferentiated" then it conflicts with principle #4.

Not too late to change your vote, Phil.

--MM