[wg-review] [Comment Please] Set timetable again or Review WG

["YJ Park \(MINC\)" <yjpark@minc.org>]

WG members and four WG leaders,

Since this group is working on review process,
every process even within this group should meet the rules and criteria.
There should be no exception on this.

Therefore, it is almost impossible for this group to have position paper
submission(only formaly done by registrar.com regarding dnso quality)
and to reach "consensus" process or position-setting process with given
time by NC.

Unfortunately, many NC members are quiet about this issue and some
members want this group to give its promised report to NC by Jan. 15.
I have seen NC extend its due date in several cases earlier, therefore,
there should be no problem. 

[Jan 15. Designated report from Review WG Chair to NC Review TF.]

Promise is promise!!
As promised, the Review WG (observation) report will be delivered to
NC review task force on Jan 15 with condition that Review WG is going 
to submit its progress report on Feb 20.

========================================
Feb 9 - 14.  Review WG Position Paper Submission
Feb 14 - 19 Review WG Position Paper Comment Period.
Feb 20         Review WG Position Paper Delivered to NC
========================================

Since this Jan 15's observation report is not going to be public position 
of  this Review working group, I am seeking your understanding on
submitting this report with bunch of papers or commments or even poll
results made in this group.

Thanks,
YJ

FYI. [Appendix 1] The first timetable of Review Working Group.

Dec. 19 - 22 : 
Review WG was formed by NC and its press release 
have been prepared.

Dec. 23 - 26 : 
The press release was announced through icann-announce list 
on Dec. 23 and WG members had its brief and informal introduction 
session.

Dec. 27 - Jan 4: 
Ten topics with questions from NC Review TF was circulated.
Three topics has been added by WG members including IDNH,
sTLD and GA chair election. However most discussion has been
focused on Constituencies - Structure - so far.

Jan 5 - Jan 9:

Call for Position Paper on each topic, 13 topics until Jan 9.

Jan 10 - Jan 11:

Comments from members on the presented position papers.

Jan 12 - Jan 14: 

Progress Report will be submitted to this group and will have
another consulation from this group before it is presented to NC.

--
This message was passed to you via the wg-review@dnso.org list.
Send mail to majordomo@dnso.org to unsubscribe
("unsubscribe wg-review" in the body of the message).
Archives at http://www.dnso.org/archives.html